GPs are ordering more than three times as many tests diagnostic for their patients as they were 15 years ago as they now provide more services previously provided by hospitals and monitor more patients with chronic diseases, shows a study published in The BMJ.
The tests are costing the NHS in excess of £2.8bn a year and ordering and reviewing their results has increased workload pressure in general practice, the authors say, led by SPCR trainee, DPhil student Dr Jack O'Sullivan from Oxford's Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences.
Using a database of patients registered with general practices, researchers at the universities of Oxford, Bristol and Southampton looked at the change in the number of tests ordered by general practices between 1 April 2000 to 31 March 2016.
They found that between 2000/1 and 2015/16 the number of tests ordered per 10,000 person years increased 3.3 fold from 14,869 to 49,267. This represents an 8.5% increase per year.
“Patients in 2015/16 had on average five tests per year, compared with 1.5 in 2000/1,” they say.
The increase in the number of tests ordered was slightly greater in men (3.4-fold increase) than in women (3.3-fold increase), and greatest in elderly patients (4.6-fold increase for patients aged over 85 years).
A total of 44 specific tests were looked at: 28 laboratory tests; 11 imaging tests; and five miscellaneous tests, such as spirometry (a measure of lung function), cervical smears, and electrocardiography (to record the electrical activity of the heart).
Significant rises in the number of tests ordered were seen for 40 of the 44 individual tests and across all three different test groups (laboratory, imaging and miscellaneous).
The researchers suggest that the increased testing might be partly due to changes to NHS service provision.
For example, over the study period, GPs’ ability to be able to order diagnostic tests (particularly imaging) expanded, many services were diverted from secondary to primary care requiring tests to be order by GPs rather than hospitals, and the Quality and Outcomes Framework, which incentivises GPs to monitor chronic diseases using laboratory tests, was introduced.
Increased testing could be a reflection of the increasing number and duration of consultations in general practice with tests being used for “strategic, non-medical reasons”, such as to reassure patients and end consultations, they add.
It could also reflect a greater expectation among patients that they should be tested as they have become more informed and been encouraged to participate in decisions about their care.
Read the full release here.
Temporal trends in use of tests in UK primary care, 2000-15: retrospective analysis of 250 million tests
Jack W O’Sullivan, Sarah Stevens, F D Richard Hobbs, Chris Salisbury, Paul Little, Ben Goldacre,Clare Bankhead, Jeffrey K Aronson, Rafael Perera,Carl Heneghan.
The BMJ 2018. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.k4666
Editorial: Use of tests in UK primary care
Emma Wallace, Tom Fahy
The BMJ 2018. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.k4895